CIC: Respondent did not list out the files destroyed by rain water flood in 2009-10 & flood is quoted as an excuse for denial of the information - CIC: Specify the alternate arrangements made to address the problem; Penalty of Rs. 25,000/ imposed on PIO
11 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Information concerning the loan account of a company was sought claiming that the appellant was a co-owner of a property which was mortgaged to the bank - CIC: Bank holds the information concerning its borrowers in a fiduciary capacity; exempt u/s 8(1)(e)
8 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
CIC: Charging of exorbitant fee of Rs. 500/- for the purpose of providing a copy of OMR Sheet to a candidate does not stand in conformity with the object & purpose of RTI Act; It is at conflict with the rules governing the field and is highly unreasonable
27 Dec, 2015
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
The reason for which an officer with neurological disorder had been retained by then public authority was sought - CIC cannot sit in judgment over whether an officer with an illness or disability should be retained in employment; exempt u/s 8 (1) (j)
7 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Information regarding the selection of the Anganwadi workers by the then District Social Welfare Officer was not provided - Respondent Officer did not come prepared for the hearing - CIC: Show cause notice for imposing penalty issued to the PIO
5 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Copy of service book of a third party would contain annual confidential reports & other information like details of family & nomination - This information is personal in nature & a Government servant has a right to guard the same - CIC: Denial upheld
1 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
The PIO was unable to explain as to how the provision of these documents would impede the process of disciplinary proceedings - CIC concluded that the PIO has deliberately denied information to the appellant - Penalty of Rs 25,000/- imposed on PIO, AIIMS
31 Dec, 2015
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Copies of the quotations submitted by the firms that carried out work on behalf of the HPCL was denied claiming that it is information of commercial confidence - CIC: Follow the procedure laid down under Section 11 of the RTI Act & take a decision
3 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Details of all the lady teachers of East Delhi, regarding the Child Care Leave taken by them was sought claiming that his wife was denied CCL - CIC: Appeal rejected as the information sought by the appellant is voluminous & is having no public interest
2 Jan, 2016
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Seeking details of birth certificates of players registered in different age categories by AITA - CIC: Allegation regarding some players getting into wrong categories by submitting false age certificates is not a ground establishing larger public interest
24 Dec, 2015
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.