Copies of the documents showing the withdrawal of appeal/writ/review petitions from various competent courts/High courts by Rajasthan Circle, BSNL - PIO: no such information is either collected by them or available in the records - CIC: denial upheld
17 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
CIC: the term “all” used by the Appellant is very vague and does not pin point the particular document she wants to obtain from the Respondents; appellant advised to be more specific and identify the documents she desires & make a de novo request to PIO
16 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
List of home loans taken by some doctors along with the address was sought alleging misuse of loans to conduct commercial activities like running nursing homes which is chargeable to higher interest rate - PIO denied it u/s 8(1)(j) - CIC: denial upheld
16 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Copies of entries in appellants service book from January 1990 till the date of his retirement were denied u/s 8(1)(b) - CIC: it is applicable only where there is an express order from the court not to disclose information, which is not the case here
13 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Respondent: FIR was lodged against the appellant in a case for misbehaving with a police personnel; complete set of judicial file including the details of phone calls sought has been provided as per court direction - CIC: no further action required
15 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
FAA: the amount of Central Excise Duty refund given under the Area based exemption Notifications does not fall in the category of commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property nor is fiduciary information - CIC: order of FAA upheld
15 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Information regarding the policy purchased by the appellant’s deceased wife - PIO: claim form B and B1 to be submitted for providing information - CIC: details of commission paid to the Agent may not be disclosed as it is third party information
13 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Action taken by the CBI against Shri Majoj Totla of M/s. Pooja Gas Service for allegedly obtaining LPG Distributorship of IOCL by submitting false documents was sought - PIO: the CBI is beyond the purview of RTI Act - CIC: no action u/s 20(1) against PIO
18 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Copies of ACRs of the appellant were denied in view of interim stay order by Madras High Court - CIC: take action for providing the scores depending on the outcome of the court case; provide the cut off marks for the promotion from Scale I to Scale II
12 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.
Certified copy of a letter & notesheet of Dept of Official Language regarding use of Hindi language in Supreme Court was denied u/s 8(1)(d) - Respondent cited section 8(1)(a) during hearing - CIC: explain how it is applicable; next hearing for May 19
11 May, 2014
Share your comments with RTI Foundation of India.